Gluten Free Cheese Traditional Pizza
One size!
15,99 $US
Sicilian Square Pizza 16"
One Size 4-5 people
21,99 $US
Sicilian Square Pizza 16" Special
Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers and extra cheese.
30,99 $US
Brother's pizza Menu (Update 2026)
Brother's Pizza delivers authentic Italian-American flavors right at 6516 Massachusetts Ave, New Port Richey, FL. This cozy, family-run spot welcomes you with warm smiles and dishes made with care, echoing the loving atmosphere of a grandmother's kitchen. Their menu offers a range of traditional and gourmet pizzas priced between $10 and $20, including a signature Sicilian Square Pizza perfect for sharing. Craving something handheld? Try their variety of hoagies like steak & cheese or chicken parm, or satisfy with crispy garlic knots and wings that diners rave about.
Open six days a week from 11 AM to 9 PM, Brothers caters to all dining styles with quick bites, small plates, and filling lunch or dinner options.
The spot boasts accessibility features, including wheelchair-friendly parking and seating, ensuring everyone can enjoy the meal comfortably. The menu's standout includes the Meat Lovers and Chicken Bacon Ranch pizzas, both loaded with premium toppings and fresh ingredients. Don't miss the garlic knots drizzled with oil and parmesan — a local favorite!
Whether you're dining in a casual setting or grabbing takeaway, Brothers Pizza offers a community vibe where every slice feels homemade. With free parking and kid-friendly options, this local gem proves that great Italian food can be both comforting and convenient for New Port Richey residents.
Interior, Food, and Ambiance
Inside Brother's Pizza, the vibe is casual and cozy, like a warm Italian kitchen where friends gather. Small plates, quick bites, and classic pizzas come with toppings piled generously. Their garlic knots, drizzled with garlic parmesan oil, become the perfect sidekick to a cheese pizza or a specialty pie. Table service is attentive but unobtrusive, letting you enjoy the meal and moment. It's a place where the aroma of baking dough invites conversation and comfort, making solo dining or family meals equally satisfying.
About Brother's Pizza
Brother's Pizza sits proudly at 6516 Massachusetts Ave, New Port Richey, FL. This Italian family-owned restaurant welcomes locals with genuine smiles and an inviting atmosphere. Serving lunch and dinner with a focus on traditional recipes, Brother's Pizza builds a community around authentic New York-style pizza. You find hot, freshly made pies with perfectly baked crusts at reasonable prices, mostly between $10 and $20. The team does not deliver but offers takeaway and dine-in options, all within a wheelchair-accessible environment. If you crave comfort food with a hint of nostalgia, Brother's Pizza delivers a taste of home with each bite.