Brother's pizza

Brother's pizza

Brother's Pizza in New Port Richey offers authentic Italian-American pizza, calzones, wings, and hoagies with a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere. Enjoy dine-in, takeaway, and delivery with wheelchair accessibility and free parking. Open daily from 11 AM to 9 PM, perfect for lunch or dinner.

Hello Dear

Welcome to Brother's pizza

Brother's pizza
Brother's pizza
Brother's pizza
Brother's pizza

Brother's Pizza invites you to savor authentic Italian family recipes right in New Port Richey, FL. Located at 6516 Massachusetts Ave, this pizza restaurant offers a cozy dining experience with an atmosphere that feels like dining in your own family kitchen. Their menu, priced between $10 and $20, features classic and gourmet pizzas baked to perfection, small plates, and comfort food favorites.

Whether you're here for a quick lunch, a casual dinner, or a solo bite, Brother's Pizza guarantees freshness and warmth in every dish. They provide takeout, dine-in, and delivery service options to suit your schedule.

At Brother's Pizza, you won't just eat a meal; you'll experience tradition and real Italian flavors, crafted with care and love you can taste.

Their welcoming staff and family-run spirit make each visit special, keeping you coming back to this neighborhood gem. Enjoy an authentic Italian-American slice of life in every pie.

Community note: Dog owners who stop by will appreciate the friendly staff’s readiness to serve you even if you come rolling in on a golf cart with furry friends in tow.

Find locations near you

Location & Contact

Address

6516 Massachusetts Ave, New Port Richey, FL 34653, United States

Hotline

+1 727-400-3220

Social

Taste the best

Food Menu

Brother's Pizza stands out with a menu packed with variety, including traditional pizzas, gourmet specialties, and a diverse range of sandwiches and appetizers. Notable items include the gluten-free cheese traditional pizza at $15.99, the generously topped Sicilian Square Pizza for 4-5 people priced at $21.99, and specialty pizzas like the Meat Lovers loaded with ham, pepperoni, sausage, beef, and bacon for $21.99.

Their garlic knots and wings receive rave reviews, praised for their perfect seasoning and heat retention even after hours. From the crispy crusts that echo New York style to the fresh toppings, every bite reflects quality ingredients and authentic preparation techniques. The menu also accommodates children with a dedicated kids’ menu and offers vegetarian options like the Veggie and Spinach White Pizzas.

Accessibility is a priority here, with wheelchair-accessible parking, entrance, seating, and toilets ensuring everyone can enjoy the friendly ambiance. Free street and lot parking remove any hassle, while Table service enhances a relaxing dining experience.

Brothers Pizza operates Monday and Wednesday through Sunday from 11 AM to 9 PM, closing only on Tuesdays. Payment is easy with credit or debit cards accepted. Whether you choose to dine in or grab a takeaway, expect prompt, friendly service from the family staff who genuinely care about your meal and comfort.

About

Brother's pizza

Brother's pizza
Brother's pizza
Brother's pizza
Brother's pizza

Brother's Pizza is a small Italian-American family business located in the heart of New Port Richey, Florida. It prides itself on serving authentic, homemade-style Italian cuisine, inspired by family traditions passed down through generations. This restaurant avoids delivery to maintain freshness and focus on quality dine-in and takeaway experiences.

The owners, Gabriel and his wife, are hands-on in both the kitchen and the dining room, ensuring that each guest feels like family. Their reputation for exceptional service is rooted in genuine kindness and attention to detail, creating a warm and welcoming environment. Many customers note the personal touches that make Brother's Pizza unique, such as personally delivered orders within the neighborhood and the warm greeting from pizza makers who treat patrons like long-time friends.

Their menu blends traditional favorites with gourmet twists, balancing indulgence and simplicity. The restaurant serves not just food but a local gathering spot where friends and families come to share good times over comfort dishes like chicken parmigiana, specialty pizzas, and garlic knots. Despite offering affordable prices, Brother's Pizza never compromises on flavor or quality, making it a beloved spot that stands out in the local dining scene.

With a commitment to inclusivity, Brother's Pizza ensures a wheelchair-accessible space so all community members can enjoy their hearty meals. They create an environment where casual meets cozy, and excellent food meets family values—a rare find that keeps customers loyal and new visitors intrigued.

Brother's pizza

Brother's Pizza commits to quality, community, and care. Rooted in family tradition, the vision is to serve food 'made with love,' echoing the secret ingredient passed down through generations. The menu, ranging from classic hoagies like steak & cheese or chicken parm to specialty pizzas, reflects a dedication to authentic flavors and customer satisfaction. Brother's Pizza aims to remain a beloved spot where excellent food and heartfelt service bring the New Port Richey community together, one delicious pie at a time.

Reviews

What Clients Say

I love Brother's Pizza. The pizza maker guy always greets you with a genuine caring smile. It feels wholesome. You know when you eat in grandma's kitchen and you ask her what's the secret ingredient then she says "Love." That's what this place is all about. I bet they put love into the food. Something about it just hits different from other pizza places.

Leslie J.
Leslie J.

Small dine-in and carry-out Italian-American restaurant. Ordered a 14 inch pepperoni and garlic knots. Pizza was cooked to perfection and was hot and ready on the spot. The garlic knots are drizzled in oil and garlic parmesan. Heated up nicely the next day as well!

Noah B.
Noah B.

Had dinner last night and I had the chicken parmiginna with pasta. It was the best. Gabriel and wife were very pleasant and the service was the best. I would 100% recommend Brothers pizza for exclent food and price. John Mackenzie

John M.
John M.

I arrived here on a golf cart with My 2 large dogs. Pizza was ready. Dogs were tethered, so I could’ve walked in, but he walked it out to me. 12 blocks home, pizza was still hot and crispy! Even with 3 toppings. This is my go to place every time!

Robin K.
Robin K.

Ordered their specialty pizza and garlic hot wings for my staff today and we all enjoyed it. Very good food and the staff is great. We will be using this place as our pizza lunch spot. Kudos to management/ownership. Great stuff here. 👏

Kelly A.
Kelly A.

I came here and asked the owner if he could live up to his review... and he certainly did. The dough is home made and results in a really nice crust. Our pizzas were baked perfectly. These are thin but not overly so. The sauce was good and cheese was at a great level. We ordered meat lovers and pepperoni. These toppings were great and not greasy. Our garlic knots and marinara were really good as well. Recommend you try this place. I am sure you will be pleased.

Phil
Phil